~ pulling this one off the shelf ~

How it works Swipe Tournament Schedule Lists Genres Compare Contact

© 2026 Omlist, LLC ·  · Privacy · Terms · Copyright · Data & credits

~ pulling its neighbors ~

12 TV shows similar to Scary Tales of New York — OmList

Swipe Tournament Lists Friends

▾

← back to Scary Tales of New York

12 TV shows similar to Scary Tales of New York

similar, not necessarily similarly great. that’s what your rec list is for.

I Will Find You

I Will Find You

2026

Dexter

2006

Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes

Conversations with a Killer: The Jeffrey Dahmer Tapes

2022

American Crime Story

American Crime Story

2016

Goliath

2016

The Sinner

2017

56 Days

2026

Lilyhammer

2012

Perry Mason

2020

The Afterparty

2022

Bad Blood

2017

Cross

2024