~ pulling this one off the shelf ~

How it works Swipe Tournament Schedule Lists Genres Compare Contact

© 2026 Omlist, LLC ·  · Privacy · Terms · Copyright · Data & credits

~ pulling its neighbors ~

12 movies similar to My First Time — OmList

Swipe Tournament Lists Friends

▾

← back to My First Time

12 movies similar to My First Time

similar, not necessarily similarly great. that’s what your rec list is for.

Love, Simon

2018

Maurice

1987

Pretty Boy

2015

My Policeman

My Policeman

2022

Below Her Mouth

Below Her Mouth

2017

Bros

2022

Tongues Untied

1990

Behind the Candelabra

Behind the Candelabra

2013

Alex Strangelove

Alex Strangelove

2018

Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex *But Were Afraid to Ask

Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sex *But Were Afraid to Ask

1972

Pillion

2025

Magic Mike

2012